Pay Band Manager, a first-of-its-kind HR solution, has launched!

Learn more
LaborIQ

Compensation | Featured | August 18, 2023

Not All Compensation Data Is Equal

Compensation benchmarking data is an essential tool for planning and developing fair and competitive pay practices that inform talent strategy, hiring plans, budgets and facilitate continuous improvement in pay practices. 

 

For those of you leveraging compensation data, but still losing employees and job candidates because of pay, it might have to do with your salary data source.

 

If you are looking to purchase market compensation benchmarking data for the first time, this can also be a guide to help you understand the various options.

 

The real key is finding the right combination of reliable data sources that fit your market, your jobs and provide in-the-moment data. 

 

Let’s look at good, better and best options. 

 

Good 

 

Published, traditional surveysfrom associations or consulting firms. These typically cover a wide range of jobs, which is a plus, but these surveys are often conducted annually and published around six months later, so they do not always reflect what is currently happening in the market and may not include newer job types. 

 

Internal company datafrom your HRIS or another internal database. While this information is a valuable way to compare pay between departments or people with the same title, it does not give you a picture of what is happening in the external market. 

 

Free, online datais readily available by pulling information from listings on job sites; however, culling through this information is time-consuming and the published ranges in job postings may make it difficult to determine the actual compensation offered to the person who accepted the role. 

 

Using this data is better than not using data at all, but the biggest reasons these sources do not make the next category are due to timeliness, sample size and data validation. 

 

Better 

 

Custom surveysthat are specific to your individual market, specially designed for your business. These are very accurate but also can be expensive. The challenge with custom surveys is that you miss what is happening in the broader market (if the survey is industry-specific). While accuracy is a plus, the timelines and size of the sample are a challenge.

 

Crowd-sourced, employee-collected datacan improve the timelines and specificity of data. Depending on the source, sample size could still be an issue for reporting on some jobs and locations. The challenge is that even “real-time” salary surveys are based on compensation rates set in the past. There is no recommended rate to offer for a current job opening based on today’s market or adjustments for the next merit cycle.  

 

When using employee-reported market data, make sure you know the validation process for the data to ensure legitimacy. Also remember that using it means that you are relying on salaries set in the past, rather than today’s going rate.

 

Best 

 

Robust and comprehensive data sets that are based on 10s of millions of salary observations across industries and locations that are validated by actual paystubs. This removes the bias of small sample sizes but still lets you customize the results by industry. 

Time-adjusted, or aged, data based on changes in the economy and labor market. By definition, salary surveys lag due to the timing of collection and depending on when the employee last had a pay adjustment. Leverage expert forecasts rather than making assumptions or using out-of-date salaries from other providers.

Specific salary recommendations based on attributes of job requirements. This is the biggest gap missing from almost all compensation benchmark providers. Having an up-to-date range of salaries is a plus, but you still need to know the exact amount to offer a new hire or for merit planning. Broad ranges still leave you guessing.

Ability to have your jobs added if they are missing so that all of your roles get benchmarked. For jobs less prevalent in certain industries or locations, traditional surveys, and other sources often will not include them. Leveraging data science helps provide answers for job titles that are not as common.

 

Good and Better provide inputs, but they lack the answers and depth of data that Best delivers.  

 

Compensation Benchmarking Data Has Evolved

 

The methodology used to benchmark salaries can give you a different insight into what it takes to attract and retain employees.

 

Methodology matters when it comes to your compensation benchmarking software and your best approach is to leverage robust data sets that are brought up to date through economic forecasting and data science.

 

Knowing the rate to offer is critical for all of your roles, and having to do guesswork is both time-consuming and risky.

Related Posts

Explore The Latest With Labor IQ

November 25, 2024

Compensation Data is The Key to Pay Transparency

Compensation

August 2, 2024

July Jobs Report Hiring slowdown, here’s what that means for employers

Featured Hiring Labor Market Reports

July 24, 2024

Why Finding A New Job Is So Hard Right Now

Featured Hiring Labor Market Reports

July 9, 2024

June Jobs Report Is the jobs report finally catching up to reality?

Featured Hiring Labor Market Reports

June 26, 2024

Simplifying Pay Bands with LaborIQ: A Step-by-Step Guide

Featured Hiring

June 7, 2024

May Jobs Report Is the labor market as strong as headline numbers suggest?

Featured Hiring Labor Market Reports

May 6, 2024

Hiring slows in April, healthcare dominates

Featured Hiring Labor Market Reports

April 24, 2024

What are recession chances in 2024?

Featured Human Resources

March 28, 2024

Keys to a Winning Compensation Strategy

Compensation Featured Human Resources

February 19, 2024

What makes a good job description?✍️

Compensation Featured Human Resources

January 26, 2024

Understanding pay for in-demand jobs

Compensation Featured Human Resources

December 22, 2023

2023 Year in Review

Compensation Featured Human Resources

November 17, 2023

Pay Bumps for New Hires

Compensation Featured Human Resources

November 1, 2023

Setting Salary Ranges in a Changing Labor Market

Compensation Featured Human Resources Salary Benchmarking

October 30, 2023

10 Questions to Set Your Compensation Philosophy

Compensation Employee Retention

September 14, 2023

LaborIQ Announces Referral Partnership with Paycor

Featured

August 29, 2023

2024 Compensation Benchmarking Guide (+ Template)

Compensation Employee Retention

August 18, 2023

Not All Compensation Data Is Equal

Compensation Featured

August 11, 2023

Know Your Company’s Compensation Health Score?

Compensation Featured Human Resources

July 7, 2023

Concealing Compensation: How It Impacts Your Business & Employees

Compensation Human Resources

June 20, 2023

How to Calculate a Market-Based Salary to Attract Top Talent

Compensation Featured Hiring

June 19, 2023

A Boomer’s Reflections on the Business Impact of Remote Work

Compensation Featured Hiring

May 4, 2023

The Costs of Keeping Compensation a Secret

Compensation

April 18, 2023

Circa Announces LaborIQ Compensation Solution

Compensation Featured

April 7, 2023

More than 1 Million Jobs Added in 2023

Featured Labor Market Reports

March 8, 2023

Inflation: What Does It Mean for the Job Market?

Featured Labor Market Reports

February 6, 2023

The Role of Backfilling Jobs and Compensation

Compensation

December 22, 2022

What SB 1162 Pay Transparency Legislation Means for Your Organization

Compensation Pay Equity

December 21, 2022

5 Keys to 2023 Compensation Planning

Compensation

December 13, 2022

Pay Transparency Laws Force Employers to Address Pay Parity

Compensation

December 7, 2022

Webinar Replay: 2023 Hiring Outlook

Compensation Hiring

November 29, 2022

7 of 10 Workers Likely to Demand the Top of the Salary Range

Compensation Hiring

October 24, 2022

Do You Trust Your Compensation Data?

Compensation Employee Retention Hiring

September 19, 2022

Inflation: How It Impacts Working Parents and Child Care Costs

Compensation Labor Market Reports

September 16, 2022

Job Swimming: Meeting Expectations

Compensation Hiring

September 16, 2022

Do you need a compensation solution?

Compensation Employee Retention Hiring

September 14, 2022

A Guide to Supporting Laid Off Employees

Compensation Human Resources

August 23, 2022

Which Compensation Data Should You Be Analyzing?

Compensation

August 16, 2022

A Step-by-Step Guide to the Compensation Planning Process

Compensation

August 11, 2022

A Handy Compensation Benchmarking Template

Compensation

August 9, 2022

What is Compensation Analysis?

Compensation

August 4, 2022

Compensation Benchmarking: Your Questions Answered

Compensation

July 1, 2022

Show Me the Money: Pay Transparency Pros and Cons

Compensation

July 1, 2022

Proactive Steps to Prepare for New Pay Transparency Laws

Compensation Pay Equity

June 16, 2022

Overcoming Compensation Management Challenges

Compensation

June 13, 2022

Removing Bias From Your Compensation Planning

Compensation

June 10, 2022

The Ins and Outs of Salary Benchmarking

Compensation

June 8, 2022

It’s More Than Money: Attracting Top Talent Beyond Compensation

Compensation

May 11, 2022

Everything You Need to Know About Compensation Analysis

Compensation

April 25, 2022

It’s That Time Again! Bring on the Mid-Year Compensation Reviews

Compensation Human Resources

April 5, 2022

Counter Offering the Counteroffer

Compensation Hiring

March 1, 2022

The Annual Increase Percentage: Why 2022 Is Different

Compensation

August 25, 2021

Key Factors in Determining the Right Salary Offer

Compensation